PhotoComments & Questions 
"Macarthur HRG130 F06"  rose photo courtesy of member Nadene
Discussion id : 127-678
most recent 29 MAY 21 HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 18 MAY 21 by Margaret Furness
Freiherr von Marschall in Australia is usually Mme Lambard. This photo reminds me more of M. Tillier.
REPLY
Reply #1 of 4 posted 21 MAY 21 by Nadene
Hi Margaret,
The roses planted in Garden bed HRG 130 are a little messy. I have taken further photos which I will post as soon as they are sorted. Hopefully the extra photos will help. Thanks Nadene
REPLY
Reply #2 of 4 posted 29 MAY 21 by Nadene
Hi Margaret,
If I may temporarily expand this Study file from F06 to the whole garden bed HRG130. It is very much muddled up, with the possibility of incorrect replacements, replacements going in back to front, old incorrect maps referenced or original planting back to front etc. There is also different roses within a group of roses.
Theoretically the order of the garden bed left (being North) to right (being South) should be General Schablikine, Mme Charles, Freiherr von Marschall, Archiduc Joseph, Francis Dubreuil. Some older maps had Suitor, Jean Ducher, Mary Guthrie and Baby Alberic. All except Jean Ducher (G. Nabbond) can be ruled out. I have posted below a sample photo of each rose or rough group of roses. I have many more photos if you need to see more of any particular rose. I have added a number and further comments within each Photo. All of these photos were taken on March 31, 2021.
REPLY
Reply #3 of 4 posted 29 MAY 21 by Nadene
Continued...
The following roses are mixed together in a 1.5m x 1.5m area HRG 130 G04
REPLY
Reply #4 of 4 posted 29 MAY 21 by Margaret Furness
Identifying roses isn't my strong point! To start with the easy ones, I'd say the reds are all "Not Francis Dubreuil" aka "Francis Dubreuil (in commerce as)". I don't think there's a G. Nabonnand among the photos. I'll call in the cavalry about the others.
REPLY
© 2024 HelpMeFind.com