'Catalogue des Rosiers, Oeillets et Auricules Cultivés par J. Sisley Vandael' comments & questions

	Photo		Comments & Questions

Catalogue des Rosiers, Oeillets et Auricules Cultivés par J. Sisley Vandael publication / article / video photo courtesy of member HMF supporting member

My HMF:

Discussion id : 122-632 most recent 16 JUL 20 HIDE POSTS

Initial post 16 JUL 20 by flodur

Is there any proof that this catalogue is from 1832?	REPLY

Reply #1 of 3 posted 16 JUL 20 by HMF supporting member

No 100% proof, however, the newest rose listed is from 1831 and there is a reference to the catalogue in "Bon Jardinier" 1833, p. xxxviii.	REPLY

Reply #2 of 3 posted 16 JUL 20 by flodur

Thanks, Le Bon Jardinier refers to Revue horticole vol. 2, p. 144: "116 espèces ou variétés de roses" and that is the number of roses you find in the catalogue! So it is 100% J. Sisley Vandael, Catalogue 1832 - 1833!	REPLY

Reply #3 of 3 posted 16 JUL 20 by HMF supporting member

Great thinking!	REPLY