PhotoComments & Questions 
Funkuhr  rose photo courtesy of Henrique Rodrigues Vivián
One or more site guests believe this photo is incorrectly labeled or inaccurate !
Discussion id : 53-748
most recent 26 APR 11 HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 25 APR 11 by anonymous-641069
I do not believe that this is a photo of the Funkuhr rose. I have several pictures of that rose.
REPLY
Reply #1 of 5 posted 25 APR 11 by Henrique R. Vivián
If you do not believe that this photo is not of FUNKUHR, discuss this matter with Kordes. I'm not interested to continue this discussion.
REPLY
Reply #2 of 5 posted 25 APR 11 by HMF Admin
Henrique,

Certainly it is possible you photographed a mislabeled plant, that happens. It's also common to find significant variation for a plant depending on the environment.

I don't believe this site guest intended their remark to be critical of your photo but it is always more helpful if one explains why they believe a photo is inaccurate and ideally follows up with some photos of their own if possible.
REPLY
Reply #3 of 5 posted 25 APR 11 by Henrique R. Vivián
I reply because is HMF ADMINISTRATION. I have told in the past that roses are "mobile"
Regards,
Henrique
REPLY
Reply #4 of 5 posted 25 APR 11 by anonymous-641069
I certainly did not intend to be critical of the photo as it is beautiful. I have mis-identified roses many times myself and would not have known had someone not pointed it out to me. Even in public rose gardens, roses are sometimes misidentified. I will post a photo of that rose that I have. Since it is no longer available commercially, to my understanding, it is probably a mute point. It is also possible that your photograph was taken from a different angle or at a different stage in the rose's development and that is why it does not look like other pictures of the Funkuhr that I have seen. In which case I apologize.
REPLY
Reply #6 of 5 posted 26 APR 11 by Henrique R. Vivián
I apologize about my stupid answer, I was not good of my head. Concerning the photo , I remember well that the rose had not the usual tint around the border, was too yellow. The climate in Azeitão is very unique so this happens frequently with similar roses. Now,seven years later , I would put a comment to avoid confusion, like suggested HMF Admin. Sorry.
Henrique
REPLY
© 2025 HelpMeFind.com