|
|
'Choť pěstitele' rose Reviews & Comments
-
-
|
The 1934 Lambert catalog (p. 45) has this as: "Derived from ["Stammt von"] Druschki. Very long pointed bud, pure white, shaded with carmine red, solitary on thornless stem, well filled; grows very strongly, blooms continuously.” "Stammt von" just means "derived from"; it's not necessarily a sport.
|
REPLY
|
Reply
#1 of 2 posted
22 SEP by
 jedmar
|
No, not necessarily. However, already in 1934 it was stated that CP is 'Marguerite Guillard' by Chambard under a new name. And MG is a sprt of Frau Karl Druschki. Jäger must have followed that train of thought in his Rosenlexikon, when he wrote that CP is a sport of FKD.
In this czech website, CP is listed as a sport of FKD:
ruze.wi.cz/cs/chot-pestitele.html
|
REPLY
|
|
In my estimation, the 1934 quote, which seems to be the origin of (false) synonymy, is not to be trusted. For instance, it calls 'General Stefanik' synonymous with 'Reine des Violettes' which it most assuredly and clearly is not (writing as one who has grown both roses).
|
REPLY
|
|
