|
|
'Golden Eye' rose Reviews & Comments
-
-
|
Available from - Proven Winners
www.provenwinners.com
|
REPLY
|
-
-
|
Starting to bloom today. Still immature, but I can tell it will be prickly, healthy, and either a mini or miniflora type shrub. The yellow is slightly deeper than Baby Love. The eye is a dark scarlet. Not purple-red like some.
Edit: Drought tolerant little bugger. Seems un-phased as a recent quart transplant by this heat. Water every 3rd day. Fade seems to be on par with Baby Love, which is fairly good for a yellow in 100F.
Edit 2: Hard to call this a climber. More like a miniflora shrublet w/ REALLY tight foliage internode spacings.
I actually really like this rose. Risa Up Amberness, on the other hand, seems to want to climb a bit. Despite the same dimensions listed by Proven Winners, they are NOT alike in anything but bloom and foliage size. So don't be fooled and plant them together, expecting the same outcome.
|
REPLY
|
-
-
Initial post
2 FEB 21 by
 Marnix
|
This consumentname is wrong. The rose and this description with this picture are all 'Gateway to Europe'. Thats why gateway is in the name CHEWgateway. The picture looks right for CHEWgateway. Golden Eye is CHEWgoldeneye and has lesser Petals compared to CHEWgateway. Other differences are the prickles. CHEWgoldeneye has lesser prickles as CHEWgateway, but that is not shown at this picture.
|
REPLY
|
|
Marnix, we do not have ‘Gateway to Europe’ listed and I cannot find it on the internet. May I have an URL please?
|
REPLY
|
Reply
#2 of 10 posted
2 FEB 21 by
Marnix
|
You did use here the name CHEWgateway, but the consumentname of CHEWgateway is 'Gateway to Europe' and not 'Golden Eye'.
|
REPLY
|
|
In Australia the large nursery Treloar Roses are selling this as ‘Golden Eye’ CHEWgateway.
I cannot find anyone selling a rose ‘Gateway to Europe’.
|
REPLY
|
Reply
#5 of 10 posted
2 FEB 21 by
Marnix
|
The Golden Eye in Australia must be written as CHEWgoldeneye and not CHEWgateway. CHEWgateway is another Rose of Chris Warner.
|
REPLY
|
Reply
#3 of 10 posted
2 FEB 21 by
Marnix
|
I cannot give you a URL, becouse it is not on the internet. This week an exemplar will arive at my garden. It is availlable at De Bierkreek in the Netherlands next Season.
|
REPLY
|
|
Aha. Next season! We will have to wait because HelpMeFind works from references.
|
REPLY
|
Reply
#7 of 10 posted
2 FEB 21 by
Marnix
|
Yes they are at the field right now growing. Becouse I am 'Friend of De Bierkreek' it was possible to get an exemplar before the introduction. But there was confusion about the names here too and today Chris Warner himselfses talked about the differences between this two Roses.
|
REPLY
|
Reply
#8 of 10 posted
2 FEB 21 by
Marnix
|
You can find it at the site of De Bierkreek right now, they added it. But I tried 3x to add the link here, but failed 3 Times.
|
REPLY
|
|
Found it. I have added ‘Gateway to Europe’ as a double rose, and changed ‘Golden Eye’ to a semi-double to double.
For the moment I have just added a Note on both roses about the code names. I will also let Treloar Nursery know about this Comment.
Very grateful for your help Marnix.
|
REPLY
|
|
Marnix, and Michael (in another comment) - thank you!
In order to find some clarification, I have added a few more references and opened a new file for
‘Peter’s Persica’ CHEWgoldeneye, introduced by Wharton’s in 202?
Searching through this wholesaler’s website, I see they also stock
‘Eye of the Tiger’ CHEWbullseye 2006 (synonym ‘Ringo’)
which looks pretty darn similar to Wharton’s photo of ‘Peter’s Persica’.
However, with ‘Eye of the Tiger’ most references call it a single, as does the patent (5-7 petals). The HelpMefind page is showing this as being semi-double to double. It seems that this should be changed to single, which I have done.
We need more references for ‘Gateway to Europe’.
At this stage we have:
‘Eye of the Tiger’ CHEWbullseye 2006 (synonym ‘Ringo’) single
‘Gateway to Europe’. CHEW……? “Years ago”.
‘Golden Eye’ CHEWgateway 2019 (syn ‘Rise Up Ringo’) double
‘Peter’s Persica’ CHEWgoldeneye, introduced by Wharton’s in 202? Single?
|
REPLY
|
-
-
|
Ordered this rose through Spring Meadow. I hope to review it in the future and edit this post for any information.
They call it RISE UP™ RINGO, and refer it to a climber, but the photos look like a pillaring miniflora. We'll see... :]
|
REPLY
|
Reply
#1 of 2 posted
4 MAY 22 by
Plazbo
|
In Australia here, so keep in mind there's some confusion between gateway/goldeneye.
You're assumptions are pretty accurate. It's either on the larger side of a miniflora bloom or smaller side of a floribunda. Long flexible (and thorny) canes that would be easy to train. It hasn't been as free flowering as other warner hulthemia hybrids (but that may just be a lack of maturity)
|
REPLY
|
|
They state it is: Rise Up™ Ringo Rosa x 'ChewGateway' USPPAF, Can PBRAF
We'll see how it goes lol.
Edit: Apparently CHEWgoldeneye is named 'Peter's Persica', and it is named after a man named Peter Seabrook. At least according to a publication called HortWeek. Any more information and they ask me to pay to read. No, thanks :P
In looking at the HortWeek photos and the Proven Winners photos, there are differences. It looks like CHEWgoldeneye has less petals, a little bit of a darker old gold tone, and a flatter form. The foliage and stems look relatively the same. CHEWgateway looks like it is a bright lemon yellow with more petals that are slightly upright. It is possible it is purely climatic.
|
REPLY
|
|
