'Madame A. Meilland' rose Member Ratings
| RATING CATEGORY | MY RATING | RATING | VOTES | | Bloom color | | EXCELLENT | 57 | | Bloom form | | EXCELLENT | 55 | | Bloom quantity | | GOOD+ | 52 | | Bloom frequency | | GOOD+ | 50 | | Fragrance | | GOOD | 46 | | Foliage | | EXCELLENT- | 47 | | Vigor | | GOOD+ | 49 | | Disease resistance | | GOOD | 45 | | Cold hardy | | GOOD | 30 | | Heat tolerance | | GOOD+ | 28 | | Shade tolerance | | GOOD | 12 | | Rain tolerance | | GOOD | 17 | | As a cut flower | | EXCELLENT- | 39 | | Exhibition qualities | | EXCELLENT | 24 |
|