HelpMeFind Roses, Clematis and Peonies
Roses, Clematis and Peonies
and everything gardening related.
DescriptionPhotosLineageAwardsReferencesMember RatingsMember CommentsMember JournalsCuttingsGardensBuy From 
'KORsilan' rose Reviews & Comments
most recent 11 MAR 12  
Initial post 11 MAR 12 by Tammy-EastTN-6a
I see that this is listed as a shrub on here, but I purchased it from Witherspoon as a rugosa...would someone be able to clarify? Thanks
Reply #1 posted 11 MAR 12 by RoseBlush
Tammy............

If you check the REFERENCES on the rose page, you can see that the rose was registered as a "shrub". Since you are a premium-member of HMF, you can also click on the LINEAGE tab and check the classes of the roses used in the parentage.

Smiles,
Lyn
Reply #2 posted 11 MAR 12 by Tammy-EastTN-6a
Thanks Lyn, I always forget about the "References" tab :)
most recent 9 FEB 09  
Initial post 29 JUN 08 by anonymous-137084
I live near Chicago (zone 5), and I put in Palmengarten Frankfurt three years ago. It has proved hardy without winter protection, and is 99% blackspot free, despite an overhead automatic watering system and only about five hours of full sun a day. It was somewhat slow to get established but is now quite beautiful. It is one of my last roses to bloom, beginning at the end of June, but its combination of good looks and disease resistance make up for the shorter season. I am delighted to have it.
Reply #1 posted 7 FEB 09 by ZZsPetals
Hi, thanks for your review of Palmengarten Frankfurt. I was wondering if you thought this would make a decent container plant? I understand this grows only 2-3' tall but what's been your experience? Thanks

Dee
Reply #2 posted 9 FEB 09 by anonymous-137084
Hi Dee,

the height is indeed only 2-3 ft., but it takes awhile to establish properly -- two or three years. So unless you live in a climate where it can winter over, I'm not sure it will reach its full glory as a container plant. Good luck!