HelpMeFind Roses, Clematis and Peonies
Roses, Clematis and Peonies
and everything gardening related.
DescriptionPhotosLineageAwardsReferencesMember RatingsMember CommentsMember JournalsCuttingsGardensBuy From 
'CLEgreengate' rose Reviews & Comments
most recent 7 JAN 23  
Initial post 7 JAN 23
* Posted by unregistered site guest: Pending HMF administrative review. *
most recent 18 MAY 21  
Initial post 18 MAY 21 by Michael Garhart
I think partially because it classified as a shrub, when its best suited as a pliable, shorter climber. And also because Heirlooms intros were gambles. Sometimes great, like Snow Ruby or The Magician, and sometimes really questionable.
Reply #1 posted 18 MAY 21 by JCP
I absolutely agree. Mine is splayed against a fence and it cascades down a rock wall.
Have you used it in breeding?
Reply #2 posted 18 MAY 21 by Michael Garhart
No. When I use something climber-ish, I trend toward using my time with a species/species hybrid in order to at least bring new genetic diversity into roses a few generations later. Climbers and species work tends to use up a lot of space, so picking your battles is wise unless you have acres just sitting there empty.
most recent 17 MAY 21  
Initial post 17 MAY 21 by JCP
Why 'The Magician' never became a well known rose, I'll never know. Excellent performance and quite the color show. Warm, fresh colors; quite cheery.
most recent 3 MAY 12  
Initial post 11 OCT 10 by Michael Garhart
It looks like a modern version of Bloomfield Dainty or Capt. Thomas.

ie. upright, smooth looking, pillar-like, refined nature. single-semi double blooms of butter yellow with salmon, cerise or orange touches as it ages. sweet scent.

I think would make a nice rose for someone's pillar that loves a delicate yellow touch to their garden. I believe it to be one of the better of the roses bred by Heirlooms.

The blooms are 3" and definitely not 5". Theyre in small, uneven clusters. this gives it a more natural charm that roses like Flutterbye do not have (which have huge symetrical clusters). I believe this would be a more popular rose if people knew it better.
Reply #1 posted 3 MAY 12 by Mike Gleason
Agreed. Also really winter hardy and disease resistant here in southeastern Michigan.