All American Magic has proven to be very hit or miss for me. Sometimes there will be the most stunning bloom on it you've ever seen. And others are just washed out messes. The bush has also been a bit of a dud for me to be honest. Hasn't been very vigorous. I once had Scentimental and didn't like it much. I've now grown AAM and Rock & Roll and neither are really that great. Rock & Roll is actually one rose I really dislike. I'm all about the stripes, but I've learned that Scentimental and any of it's offspring are best avoided.